Especially since, as of last year, it's illegal for restaurant owners to pool these tips and distribute them among servers and other employees unless they pay everyone the full--not tipped--minimum wage. But there are much bigger problems with our current tipping practice.
For one thing, research shows that tipped workers, such as servers, are much more vulnerable to sexual harassment from customers than their non-tipped co-workers. It's easy to see why. If a drunken diner is making unwanted sexual advances, telling him to stop or complaining to the manager may mean losing that customer's tip, which is part of your livelihood. It's much safer to just put up with it. Not only that, tipping is discriminatory. Preliminary research suggests that restaurant customers of both races routinely tip white servers more than black ones.
That being the case, today's tipping practices might actually be illegal under the Civil Rights Act of , researchers claim. That law prohibits employment discrimination based on race, gender, religion, or national origin. The Supreme Court has held that an employer may not have business policies that create the effect of discriminatory treatment, even if those policies appear neutral and were not intended as discriminatory.
That means restaurants could be held liable if their tipping policies result in non-white servers--or female, Muslim, homosexual, or immigrant servers--earning less than their colleagues.
If tipping is so bad in so many ways, shouldn't somebody try to stop it? Indeed they should, and they are. By , all of the states had repealed anti-tipping laws. As a restaurant owner, be sure to fully understand the Fair Labor Standards Act as well as relevant state laws before making any decisions.
If you require quick advice or an employee contract review, Avvo offers easy legal services related to business formation. Also, the legal information herein is intended for general informational purposes only and is not the provision of legal services.
Please acknowledge that such information consists of third-party data and contributions, that there are certain inherent limitations to the accuracy or currency of such information, that legal and other information may be incomplete, may contain inaccuracies, or may be based on opinion. Skip to content. Marlo Spieth. April 30, — 4 mins read. Managers and owners have no right to tips.
Not all states have tip credits. Some believe tipping should be eradicated for its discriminatory ties to race and gender. Is it less hard to work at a roadside diner than Le Bernardin, where the check averages are approximately ten times higher?
Although that one isn't entirely fair; a place like Le Bernardin is dividing the tip among a much larger staff. Diners love the power to bestow or withhold financial reward at their whim; servers, in turn, seem to be motivated by the idea that really excellent service could be rewarded by a monster gratuity.
The trouble is, that's not actually how things pan out in practice. Michael Lynn , a professor at Cornell's School of Hotel Administration, has spent his career researching tipping behaviors, and found that perceived service quality only accounts for two percent of the variation between tips.
Two percent! It's probably not even enough to be picked up on by the server, much less cause a significant change in behavior. Lynn's research also shows that tip amounts are affected by racial and gender discrimination.
Female servers get larger tips than male servers; sexy women earn more than frumpy ones; white servers, more money than their black counterparts — regardless of what the perceived quality of service is. The system works the other way, too.
Black diners tip less on average than do white diners, and research shows that servers provide black diners with inferior service as a result. The tipping system catches us all in a regressive cesspool of our own worst prejudices. Backlashes against the tipping practice are not new.
There was an anti-tipping movement at the beginning of the 20th century amongst Americans who saw it as an aristocratic holdover contrary to the country's democratic ideals. Between and six states passed anti-tipping laws, all of which were repealed by the mid's as unenforceable or potentially unconstitutional. Samuel Gompers, who founded the AFL, was one political figure notably outspoken against tipping as promoting detrimental class distinctions.
According to a report by the Restaurant Opportunities Centers United, the restaurant industry is "the single-largest source of sexual-harassment charges filed by women with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission EEOC.
In fact, the people most likely to sexually harass waitresses are their customers — 78 percent of waitresses reported that customers made lewd comments or have sexually harassed them in some way. And while there can be recourse, if you file a complaint or say something about the customer to your manager, you're likely to lose out on those tips, which are your primary source of income.
And that it's been that way since ? Sounds crazy, right? But it's true, and it's standard practice. The idea is that servers will generate enough money from their tips, making up for the minuscule wage business owners legally have to pay their tipped employees in all but seven states.
You can see now just how important those tips are. If you do well and work in a restaurant that has decent business, especially in certain regions in the US, you'll probably be okay. And employees who don't make adequate sums are supposed to be compensated by their bosses.
But that isn't always a guarantee; the US Department of Labor reported a whopping 84 percent violation rate of employers not making sure their employees received proper payment.
This could be easily solved with a required service fee, which would render tipping obsolete. Or, pay tipped workers the full minimum wage as base pay, which will keep more workers out of poverty. If you work for an established bar or restaurant that's always packed, chances are you're doing pretty well, wage-wise. And you can probably predict your income with relative accuracy, which in turn allows you to calculate money for living expenses without worrying about how different things might be from one week to the next.
But things become problematic if you're working for a new restaurant that doesn't yet have a dedicated customer base, or for a business that's under-performing to no fault of your own. In these situations, servers can end up in a fairly uncertain income situation.
It's hard to argue in favor of tipping when it creates so much uncertainty. Putting the power of employee compensation in the hands of customers, rather than the employing establishment, leaves tipped workers at risk of discrimination. For example, one study showed that African-American servers are tipped less than their non-black counterparts by customers of all ethnicities.
0コメント